Here are four simple ways to drive yourself crazy (or to drive other writers & readers crazy!):
1. Think the very first book you’ve ever written is ready for publication.
This is a very hard truth for beginning writers to swallow. No one wants to believe they’ve gone to all the hard work of writing a book for nothing. But if you ask most published authors how many books it took them before they were ready for publication, likely you’d get a range from 4 to 6. Sure there are exceptions. But the large majority of authors have to write multiple books before really honing their skills.
It took me five books (not to mention a couple of books that I started but never finished). Those five books are stuck in a closet and will never see the light of day.
Fortunately, all the work isn’t for nothing. In fact, those first couple of unpublishable books are incredibly important. Without mine, I wouldn’t be where I’m at today. The practice books—combined with studying fiction techniques—are the building blocks for a successful career.
We’ll only drive ourselves crazy with potential rejections, poor sales, and crushing feedback if we attempt to put our books out there too soon.
2. Think you don’t need time to grow.
I save my kids’ writing assignments. They date the papers and put them in their writing folders. Every year when they add new paragraphs, essays, and stories, they invariably go back and read what they’ve written in previous years. Now in seventh grade, my daughters giggle over what they wrote in second grade.
But, boy, in second grade they thought those stories were wonderful. And they were—for a second grader. However, the time, distance, and growth has helped them to look back and see how much deeper, richer, and more complex they’ve become. They can objectively see just how shallow and simplistic their earlier writing was.
Even though there’s no set number of years someone needs to write before being ready for publication, there’s something to be said for giving ourselves plenty of growing room. If we’re studying hard, over time we’ll begin to see improvements in our writing skill. And someday we’ll even look back at our earliest attempts and giggle (at least I do!).
3. Think you can catch all your own mistakes.
No one can edit his or her own manuscript perfectly. That’s a little bit like trying to give yourself counseling. Usually we can’t see our own issues and faults (or we’re prideful or in denial!). We need friends, family, and therapists to help us see the issues.
And the same is true in our writing. No matter how many times we read our manuscript, we can’t view it as objectively as someone who is reading with a fresh perspective.
Even with twenty plus years of writing experience, I still can’t catch all my own mistakes. I absolutely need a critique partner and editors who can give me their honest, careful, and detailed critiques (of both big and small problems).
4. Think you can make a go of the writing journey alone.
In this modern age, it’s pretty tough to go solo. Although writing a first draft of a book is a solitary endeavor, the road beyond that is not.
The longer I’m in the industry, the more I’ve come to realize just what a team effort the process of publication is—everything from the editing to the marketing. Yes, it takes a team effort to take a book in its somewhat rough state and to polish it up so that it can really resonate and shine.
But then once we have it sparkling, it also takes a team to help us market our books. With over one million other books vying for the reader’s attention, we have so much more of a chance of getting our books to stand out when our friends and online connections help us spread the word.
Plus, as I mentioned in my post about the insecurities that come after publication, we need writing friends to help us through the difficult times. Yes, our non-writing friends and family can support us too. But other writers can get it in a way that others often can’t.
We can drive ourselves crazy, sometimes even to the point of wanting to quit when we fall prey to any of the above. How about you? Do you agree or disagree with my points? Are there exceptions to the above that you’ve seen?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)















42 comments:
Seriously, Jody, your advice is gold. I've made almost all of these mistakes at some point.
Thanks, Paul! I've made most of these mistakes too! And I drove myself crazy! :-)
I agree with all of those! I remember thinking my first completed novel was good. OMG, I can't bring myself to look at that manuscript now. I don't think there's anything there I could use, even one senetence! But, it got me started, which is important. Very good list. I think #1 and 2 are the biggies. No...all of them. Good advice. :)
Yep, I really thought my first manuscript was publishable. I thought it was not only publishable, but really, really good.
I got a request for a full from a publishing house, sent the manuscript to them, and promptly received it back in the mail.
I was so disillusioned. I seriously thought that if a publisher would just READ it, they would see the grandness of the story and publish it.
Now, the story is tucked away somewhere in my computer and I wouldn't even think of showing it to my agent.
Even my debut novel, which was the third manuscript I wrote, makes me a bit nervous....I've written three more since. So even though this one is getting published, I feel insecure about it. Because I know my writing has improved.
God's teaching me a lesson in letting go and trusting that if He wants it published, then He must have some people in mind who He wants to read it.
Jody, Those four points--like most of the lessons I've learned in life--I came to recognize by ignoring them and fouling up as a result. Thanks so much for sharing your experience.
I think all four points are spot on. Number three is a big one for me. There are so many things that I just don't see, so having another set (or two!) of eyes can make a big difference. Sometimes we just can't see it because we know what should be there, sometimes it's because we're too close to the project. Either way, the team behind the writer is crucially important.
Experience is the best teacher in this respect. I think we've all learned these lessons the hard way!
My fourth novel was the one that sold. When it comes out next month (eep!), it will mark fourteen years of writing with an eye toward publication.
Waiting was KILLER, but my work wasn't ready before now. I'm glad the way it all played out.
I wrote three books around 5 years ago; they were terrible and my computer managed to swallow them up. Never seen them since but I have around 5 incomplete books saved somewhere now...I hope the current one gets published one day.
These are all excellent points, but I've got to confess, #1 (along with published authors agreeing to it in the comments) is quite discouraging. I've technically written only one other novel—although I didn't take the time to write other drafts of it beyond the first—so to think of my current WIP as a stepping stone or learning experience is a bummer... just being honest. Even so, I don't deny the wisdom in your post, and with me, it's a case of hoping for the best but preparing for the worst.
Barb, Thanks for your honesty. I didn't want this post to discourage writers who are on their first couple of books. Because, there are definitely writers who've been able to have success with their first book. But, the majority have many books under their belts before publication (and sometimes newer writers just aren't aware of that).
Anyway, all that to say, everyone is spot on with saying we learn from experience. Sometimes it take sending that book to an agent or publisher before we know. And for those who self-e-publish too soon, the poor sales and/or bad reviews will likely be the wake-up call.
I guess the important thing is NOT to be in too much of a rush. But to do all we can to be ready before we publish.
I was on CRACK when I thought I could make a go of writing alone! (not literally, but you get the idea). I would be LOST without my writing community. Even the encouragement during the ups and downs of life that "get in the way" of writing, but yet, are all a part of God's perfect timing ... you all are great! Writing community is NUMERO UNO in my book (pun intended). :)
Nice tips. I especially like 3 and 4. Three is imperative for any writer. And you always need a reading or writing buddy with you on your journey or at least an avid supporter or community to keep you encouraged.
I think I'm guilty of the first three, especially. My second book is the one on submission, and I'm hoping to have some luck with e-publishers. One of my big issues is worrying about wasting time and getting upset when I don't catch small mistakes. Having to come to terms with those two things is an ongoing process.
Thanks!
Yep, having a writing buddy...or several...has really made the difference for me. I have three friends who are professional editors and writers and boy do they give GREAT advice!
Thanks for the post!!
I love your blog, Jody. You always have such great advice. Your insight always seems to come in perfect timing. Thank you!
In answer to your "writer's need social interaction in order to better their writing" my friend KT Hanna has formed something I think will take off over the years. It's on Twitter and we use the hashtag #WriteMotivation Here's more about it: http://www.kthanna.com/2011/12/writemotivation-and-progress/
We all need it. :) Hope you can join! We welcome everyone!
So, I'm procrastinating today.
I was reading Barb's comment and it got me thinking....
When I wrote my first novel, and even my second, I was convinced that they would be published. And I think that's a VERY good thing. Because if, at the time while writing them, I told myself, "These are just stepping stones." I most definitely would have lost a lot of that fire and wonder and anticipation that comes when we're writing our first manuscript.
It's important to believe in that first manuscript while we're writing it. It's important to dream and hope.
However, with time and distance and the more you write, the more you'll see improvement and the less desirable that first manuscript will look. It's a slow revelation. Not something we should cling to as we're writing the first draft. If that makes any sense at all.
Heck, I think I might just write a post about this and link to Jody's post.
Katie and Jody, your thoughts & further explanations are much appreciated. I *do* understand the necessity of a learning curve and continue to read books on my craft as well as keeping my butt-in-the-chair to write daily—and to believe in my story more so than being consumed with the rush to want to be published. If only I were ten years younger... LOL just kidding.. sort of... Thanks, you two. :)
I hear that first piece of advice all the time, and have heard it from the beginning, but it still scares me a little bit :) I'm about finished with the first draft of my first novel, and like you said, I would hate to think that it's never going to see the light of day. I've been a voracious reader since I was little, taken creative writing classes since seventh grade, and this is probably the 7th novel I've started, though the first to be finished, I've read lots of writing books and was very careful in my outlining of this MS, so my prayer is that all that combined makes up for it being a first novel, and counts as paying my first novel "dues" :) We'll see. I'll be starting a second one as soon as this is finished, so whatever else, just keep going, right?
Sarah Allen
(my creative writing blog)
I totally agree with Barb's post. I have just finished the first draft of my first novel. At this point, I'm just happy to have it finished, but I'm also hoping to edit it and submit it to agents. So...how do I know if something is really publication ready? Is it foolish to try to submit it to agents? I suppose if all I get is rejections, then I can move on to another story, and maybe I'll get some good advice and perspective from them...
It's hard for me to know where I fall, because I do have experience with publication and writing--I have a BA in journalism and MA in English--but not with novel writing, though I've read craft books and such.
I think all I can do is my best, make my current novel as "ready" as possible, and submit away, praying and seeing what happens. Any other advice about knowing when to "move on" to another novel? Thanks, Jody!
#1 is probably very accurate but extremely scary for those of us on our first *real* completed novel.
Great post, Jody! Great advice for all!
I was at #1 about ten years ago. Boy did that drive me crazy.
Excellent points, Jody. That first one I think is hard for all of us. I think we too frequently miss the fact that we actually wrote a book and need to celebrate that success, but realize there's a bit more to be done. :)
Thanks for this. I'm just slogging thru the edits of a major historical novel, will turn it over to the pro editor next month. This part (the editing) is trickier than the writing but of course it has to be important and done well. And you certainly need to be determined!
Great list Jody! I love that you get your children's stories out again that's a great idea. Time really tells you so much. Patience is a virtue. My motto for next year :)
Lindsay Harrel asked: How do I know if something is really publication ready? Is it foolish to try to submit it to agents?
My thoughts: Lindsay, one of the best ways to know is to get your work in front of qualified critique partners. Let them give you feedback. Sometimes contest feedback can help you know where you're at in the "pack."
If you start to get feedback that indicates you're getting close to publication, then go ahead, send out your MS. It won't hurt to see what happens!
But in the meantime, don't wait to see what happens. Just start the next book and keep on writing! :-) I agree with what Sarah Allen said, "Whatever else, just keep going."
Katie said: When I wrote my first novel, and even my second, I was convinced that they would be published. And I think that's a VERY good thing. Because if, at the time while writing them, I told myself, "These are just stepping stones." I most definitely would have lost a lot of that fire and wonder and anticipation that comes when we're writing our first manuscript.
My thoughts: Hi Katie! Thanks for chiming in! And I DO hope you'll write a post outlining your thoughts further! I think there is some underlying motivation that comes with letting the dream of "publication" drive us. In some ways, shooting for publication can push us to work harder and make our books better (than say someone who is merely writing for personal pleasure).
However, the longer I'm doing this, the more I realize that "publication" in and of itself can't be the end goal. I really have to write my stories because I LOVE telling stories and because writing itself brings me great satisfaction. If I'm not, then once we get past publication and have one of those identity crises that I talked about last week, then we won't have the staying power.
When I wrote The Preacher's Bride (my 1st published book but about the 6th book I'd written), I didn't really aspire for publication while I was writing it. I wrote it because I had an idea that germinated into a story that I wanted to tell. And it wasn't until I was done and started to get some feedback that I decided to send it out there.
So, while I completely understand what you're saying, I also urge us all to make sure we're not just writing for publication but for love.
Jody- Pretty sure I've been guilty of all of these except for trying to go it alone. I've realized that the network of people God has introduced me to on this journey are a wealth of information and friendship.
As for my first manuscript, I totally thought it was amazing. I realize now that it was pretty much crap. But I LOVE that story and my characters so much! Now that I'm so much farther away from it and I've learned and grown and continue to do so, someday I'm determined to go back to that first manuscript and make it work. Someday. For now I'll concentrate on creating other stories I love and pray that publication will come.
I completely agree with all your points. I'm in a critique group and hired a freelance editor for the book I'm about to self-publish on Amazon and Smashwords. It took me five tries as far as the novel. The four rookie books I've scrapped. The first two make me laugh, and the 3rd an 4th are entertaining to me, but probably not to the rest of the world.
I understand what you're saying, Jody. I would never encourage writers to write because they want to be published. I'm assuming most writers write because they genuinely LOVE writing and telling stories. If that love isn't there, then well....I guess I don't understand why somebody would even start this journey.
So my comment was made with the underlying assumption that the biggest motivation is a love to write.
I'm just saying that when I wrote my first novel, I believed in it. Believed in it enough to think it had a shot at publication. And I think that was a good thing - to have that hope and that sense of excitement. Because, at least for me, a part of the magic was the dream/hope that maybe, must maybe, it'd be good enough to share with others.
Which gets at the question....why do we write? Sure, we write because we love it. But I think most of us write with a hope that we can share our words and stories with others. Publication lets us do that.
Well, if this isn't a fun conversation, I don't know what is. :)
I meant to write: maybe, JUST maybe...
Not MUST maybe.
Oy!
Thanks, Jody. I appreciate advice from those who have "gone before" me. :) I think it's a hard thing, since writing is such an individual journey in terms of what works, what doesn't, how long the journey takes, etc. I guess we all just need to keep working hard and keep advice in mind as we go.
I'm hoping to enter a few contests like you suggest and am currently asking a few critique partners their thoughts. So I guess I'm right on track with your advice! :P
I love all these comments and the post is superb.
I tried to "fix" my first novel for many years until I had to realize I was beating a dead horse. (And there were conveniently horses in that story...)
I wrote a second novel and then a third and am now coming back to re-write that first one completely. I have found new plot twists, new characters, and new meanings in that first beloved story and I am enjoying every step of this process.
I'm still unpublished but my agent and I are shopping that third complete manuscript that I finished.
I love what you said, Jody, about writing not with publication as the end goal. That is where I'm at. Though I'm doing all I can to be published, I'm writing because I have to.
Not writing is simply not an option.
:-)
I agree with ALL your points! It was tough to swallow the "practice book" idea, but it's so true. The best thing I ever did was start the next project. And then the next.
Merry Christmas to you and your lovely family!
I try, try, try to catch all my mistakes ... and am surprised at how much I need to edit/tweak/change/overhaul every editing cycle! During the galley proof stage of my ms, I read through it twice and my husband read through it once. We were each catching things the other person missed. My husband was the one who caught the fact that in one chapter my hero's name had suddenly been changed from Daniel to David.
Huh?
Still not certain how that happened!
Merry Christmas, Jody!
Thanks for this post. It's all stuff I've scolded myself for thinking/doing. Hearing a successfully published author make these points is...well, sort of encouraging. It lets me know I'm not alone. How is it we all do the same stuff? Is human nature really that predictable?
Oh TRUST ME, I know how horrible my first book is. ;-)
My near mistake is when I was a senior in high school, my job was to finish my first novel and see what we could do with it as my senior project. We talked about writing a letter to someone at Bethany House (my favorite publishing house) and asking them to mentor me.
Gulp!
Thank GOODNESS I NEVER wrote that letter. Not even a rough draft. I kind of cringe at that now. ;-)
It's amazing what a little perspective and learning with do for you. :D
Thank you Jody! I have so much farther to grow and this keeps me grounded.
Your first two points may be difficult for first time novelists to accept, but in retrospect we know they're true. The difficulty is in reaching the point where we have that perspective. I hoped my first manuscript was publishable, but knew when I was writing it that it had weaknesses. I didn't understand what they were until much later, after I'd studied the craft a lot more.
Completing a first novel is a great achievement. I compare it to writing an English term paper and getting a good mark for it. It's a satisfying accomplishment, but it doesn't mean we've passed the course yet. Even when we pass that course, there are more courses to conquer before we can claim a degree. And not everyone with an English degree has the ability to reach PhD status.
Thank you ALL for the excellent comments and stimulating discussion on this topic! I've really enjoyed hearing all of your thoughts!
Thank you for the article and for your blog in the first place. It has helped me a lot!
The point I have the most difficulty with is the 4th one, doing it alone. Not because I think I should, but because I don't have much of an option.
If it weren't for the internet, and all the kind people sharing some wisdom and support through it, I don't think I would be writing now.
I intend to start working on that, because writing is already such a lonely process with support from friends. When you don't have that, and the closest people in your life don't support you, not talking about it, asking questions, or getting feedback can be maddening. If the web is the only place where I can get support, so be it. It's not a bad place to go for help anyway. ;)
Happy holidays and lots of success to you! :)
Thank you. Funny how when you start out you have a whole set of expectations. I suppose that's why it's called a learning curve, right. [when I wrote that the first time, I wrote 'learning curse' ]
Hi Maddy! Thanks for jumping into the discussion on several posts today! Appreciated hearing your perspectives! And yes, LOL there is indeed a learning curse! :-)
Post a Comment