If you’ve been reading my blog long enough then you’ll know I feel very strongly that writers need to grow in their writing ability by reading fiction how-to books. I blogged about it in this post: My Writing Success: The One Thing That Has Helped Me The Most.
Back in the days when I was first writing seriously (about twenty years ago), I devoured every how-to book I could get my hands on. I filled notecards with all of the things I was learning. And as I wrote, I’d flip through my notecards to help me remember everything.
Incidentally, I still have that stack of notecards and occasionally still read them. And I still regularly read writing craft books (usually when I’m between projects so that I can refresh myself and find new inspiration) (for a few of my favorites scroll down through my sidebar).
Now I realize not everyone agrees that writing craft books are helpful. Some people become overwhelmed by all of the information. Others feel stifled. Some even get discouraged to the point of quitting because they can’t seem to do things “by the book.”
Then there are those writers who don’t want anyone else telling them what to do. They feel that writing is an individualistic, subjective expression of our creativity (just like all of the other art forms).
Some may even say you can learn all you need by reading well-written novels and that the rhythm of story and structure is picked up through saturating ourselves with a variety of genres and stories (including the classics). Such writers might say things like, “Story trumps technique.”
The fact is, writers can come up with any number of excuses for why they don’t want to learn the basics of fiction-writing. And sometimes those excuses may even be valid, because after all, most excuses usually have a hint of truth to them, don’t they?
The truth is yes, sometimes we can try too hard to follow the rules and in the process get discouraged or end up with sterile writing. Sometimes we’re at risk of losing our individuality and creativity when we try to make ourselves fit into a prescribed structure. And yes, those of us who are avid readers may have a leg-up on how to tell a good story. Indeed, the story itself is critically important.
But the other truth is this—very few people are born as writing geniuses. I certainly wasn’t. Most of us have to learn how to write fiction similar to any other subject like typing, reading or algebra. And while there are many ways to learn how to write, one of the best ways to learn anything is to STUDY and then PRACTICE.
Here are few suggestions that might make the process of learning about writing fiction less painful:
1. Wait to read a how-to book until after you’ve completed your first manuscript. Often we don’t know what we need to work on until after we’ve had some firsthand experience. Besides, there’s something about giving yourself freedom with the first book to explore, be creative, and to nurture your imagination.
2. Check out several fiction how-to books from the library. When I’m able to browse through a book first, I’m able to see whether it’s going to contain information that will help me. Different books will speak to us more or less depending upon where we’re at in our writing journey. If we’re not selective, we might give up on how-to books too easily instead of continuing to search until we find one that meets our needs.
3. As you’re reading, take notes on specific things you’d like to work on in the next novel. I usually read a how-to book when I’m in the pre-writing plotting phase, which helps inspire ideas and reminds me of what I need to incorporate.
4. Don’t try to work on everything all at once. That’s a bit like having too many cooks in the kitchen—a recipe for disaster (or at the very least discouragement). Trying to do everything perfectly or too much to soon can zap the joy out of writing and lead to writer’s block.
5. Look at writing techniques as guidelines not rules. I examine the “why” behind particular guidelines. What is the point of a technique? For example, plenty of books advocate against using adverbs. Why? Because the modern reader doesn’t want to be slowed down by wordiness. They want a succinct, tight read. But does that mean we can’t use any adverbs? No, if I’m doing my job at keeping the story moving, then if I drop in an adverb here and there, it won’t bother the reader or slow my story.
6. Find a balance. Don’t focus too much on technique at the expense of your story or it will end up lifeless. But also don’t ignore the building blocks of good fiction because you think you have an awesome best-selling story. You might shoot your chance with an agent, publisher, or reader simply because they’re tripping over your presentation.
How about you? Are you taking enough time to work on your fiction techniques? What writing book has helped you the most from a practical standpoint?
5 Steps to Building Your Platform [Infographic]
13 hours ago











24 comments:
Good morning, Jody! Of course, I share your love for James Scott Bell's Plot and Structure!
Recently, I read a craft book, Hooked: Write Fiction that Grabs Readers from Page One and Never Let's Them Go. This was a great book for mastering beginnings, which I was struggling with a little.
Also, the most helpful thing I've done recently is watched videos by Dan Wells on his plot and structure methods. Loved these!! Writers can find them on You Tube. There's five of them all together, and they're not super long.
Hey Jody. I've not read a craft book in awhile, when I was in school studying writing. However, I just finished writing the first draft of a novel, so I will likely take a look at a few craft books soon. Thanks for the informative post!
Plenty of sage counsel here, Jody. When I began writing stories I didn't know any of the fiction "rules." I'd focused on non-fiction to that point.
Upon learning all the things I was "supposed" to do to get it "right," I became overwhelmed. Eventually I learned to think of the rules as generally accepted guidelines, and that freed me to tell my stories without feeling so constrained that the joy evaporated.
#'s 4 & 6 really resonated with me, personally. I'm one of those writers who has bought or borrowed every self help book out there I can get my hands on--and found not everyone was worth my money. Now, I'm more realistic, finding the authors (like Susan May Warren) who I know teach and communicate really well and that is what I choose to invest in. :)
Good Morning, Jody! I began writing over 20 years ago also, with a brief respite to care for a chronically ill family member.
Initially, I devoured every self-help book I could find. I took classes, joined writer's organizations, and learned the craft of writing. I think all of those are musts in writers' careers. Sometimes, too, when I've felt a bit stifled, I've written by "gut instinct." Your points are all right on the money! Thanks for the reminders. :)
Good morning everyone! Thank you all for sharing your thoughts! And I'm really looking forward to hearing what your favorite/most helpful craft books (or sites, or mentors) have been! I'm always on the look out for new books to discover--because the learning never ends! :-)
I love books on the writing craft, and I too go back to my favorites. With my first books, I had a good sense of story and how to create a logical plot, but it wasn't until I studied craft books that I truly understood scenes and how to effectively up the stakes throughout the book. I'm always learning. I'll always be learning!
Helpful tips, Jody! I also like to read craft books between projects. And if I find myself hit with a frustrating case of writers block during a project, usually skimming one of my favorites gives me that extra boost to break through.
I love how-to-write books. One of my favourites is Elizabeth George's 'Write Away'. I've only just read James Scott Bell's 'Plot & Structure' and it really struck a chord (should have read it ages ago). I also got a lot out of Leslie Wainger's 'Romance Writing for Dummies'. These books and lots of others help to strengthen our writing.
I really enjoyed reading this post. You've succinctly expressed what I have been feeling as I've gone between reading about writing and doing the actual writing itself. I like to read about the craft, then read some fiction and see how what I learned is applied. Educational as well as entertaining and inspiring!
Great post. I need to STEP AWAY from the writing books & blogs for a while and finish my first draft. I agree on waiting until after the first draft; then I really know what I need to work on!
Hi Jody, Great post as usual! It seems a lot of authors, at all stages are writing about this lately.
I find myself enjoying better the diversity to reap bits and pieces online, or whats mentioned by some authors on blogs who really want to help other authors in their writing process. It seems quicker. But one has to remember to bookmark a lot, and remember to refer back there.
My own blog today for instance is covering links on 'deep POV' and two authors with novels out, who show this factor in their novels.
However I have down loaded a few free books on writing lately.
Maria Zannini also raves a mention on her blog today, a link for a book called 'Writers Companion.'
Here's the Smashwords link to 'Writers Companion.'
http://www.smashwords.com/books/view/92367
Have a great week!
Okay, my itchy hives aren't too bad on this, because this advice is perfect--and pretty much spot on for a "pantster" like me. :) I read my first craft book after I'd finished my first manuscript and I'll admit that I'm a different writer now-- several books, rewrites, edits, and projects later-- than I was then. :)
When I started writing fiction I had already been writing non-fiction (mostly Bible studies) for years. How thankful I was for the books I found on learning the craft of writing fiction. What a difference the things I learned from these books made as I undertook a task vastly different from my non-fiction writing experience.
I've completed two novels now, but still periodically reread one of my books on writing fiction, or review notes I've taken at a writer's conference. For me, both are beneficial in helping me remember what's important in crafting a good, strong story.
I haven't found one that stands out... But I still have many to read.
I love your first point and would even go so far as suggesting to wait til you've revised that first ms... The check out some how to books.
Xx
I find Dwight Swain's book, "Techniques of the Selling Writer", really helpful, and try to re-read it every so often to remind me of the concepts.
Hi Jody,
I have a few note cards with ideas from a few craft books. I usually look at them when I'm starting a new story.
Great tips Jody! I definitely did number one, but boy did I need to read a book! ;)
Hi Jody, another thought provoking, informative blog. Thanks. I like creative writing text books, or at least some of them. The right text book can not only help you develop or hone your writing skills, it can give much needed encouragement when you feel you are wavering (especially helpful in such a lonely profession as 'writing'!). One of my favourite books of this kind is Anne Lamott's Bird by Bird Some Instructions on Writing and Life. It was first published in 1994, but still full of good advice, and very uplifting if you are questioning your abilities as a writer - and very funny.
Hi Jody, Thanks for an interesting discussion. I so glad to hear I'm not the only one with a bookcase full of "how-to" books. I learned first through workshops, seminars and so on, then did my MFA which helped tremendously - exposing me to craft courses, as well as workshops and directed reading. For the craft of fiction, if people are looking for a text-style book (complete with exercises and good examples to illustrate concepts) I'd recommend Writing Fiction, by Janet Burroway and Elizabeth Stuckey-French; and Deepening Fiction (intermediate and advanced) by Sarah Stone and Rod Nyren. One of my favourite "non-texts" is Bird by Bird by Anne Lamott -- she's is very entertaining and gets her point across in a non-preachy way.
Hey, everyone! Thank you for the book suggestions! I'm going to be checking some of them out! :-)
From a practical standpoint Scene and Structure by Jack Bickham (though soon I can't wait to compare that to Plot & Structure by James Scott Bell) and at the other end of the scale on a more 'add colour to your craft' kind of book, I really like Second Sight by Cheryl B. Klein.
Great post, Jody. When I was just beginning my career, I subscribed to Writers Digest Books and accumulated a library of how tos that I still refer to from time to time. I agree with Leigh's recommendation of Elizabeth George's Write Away. I love Robert Newton Peck's Fiction is Folks for character development and Chris Vogler's two volumes of The Writers Journey for plot and structure. Most recently I've loved Stan Williams' The Moral Premise.
Quite a good read. I will be sharing this to other friends of mine so they can have a good thing to read and a guide as well. ethics and compliance solutions
Post a Comment